Page 2 of 2

Re: Sign restriction - Historical Decomposition

Posted: Wed Oct 22, 2014 12:51 pm
by TomDoan
if UhligAccept(a,KMIN,KMAX+1,||+5,-1,-3,-4||)==0

If I'm reading your model correctly, you have a restriction with one interest rate going up (+5) and one down (-3) for five consecutive periods. That sounds like it would be hard to achieve.

Re: Sign restriction - Historical Decomposition

Posted: Thu Nov 27, 2014 9:00 am
by cordura
Dear Tom,

I am working on an empirical study using sign restriction, identifying multiple shocks. I am wondering if there are any possibilities that RATS can realize the plotting of structural innovation of each shocks?

cheers

Re: Sign restriction - Historical Decomposition

Posted: Thu Nov 27, 2014 10:41 am
by TomDoan
cordura wrote:Dear Tom,

I am working on an empirical study using sign restriction, identifying multiple shocks. I am wondering if there are any possibilities that RATS can realize the plotting of structural innovation of each shocks?

cheers
Sure. That's much simpler than the historical decomposition. For an accepted draw using weights A, you just take a series formed by TR(A)*INV(SWISH)*XT(U,T). Whether that will be particularly interesting is another matter---I'm guessing that the bands across draws will be quite wide.

Re: Sign restriction - Historical Decomposition

Posted: Tue May 05, 2015 8:54 am
by luching
Hi Tom, I have a VAR with 2 variables only. In this system, is it possible to impose two sets of sign restrictions to identify two different structural shocks simultaneously and also impose that the two shocks are orthogonal? Doesn't this result in some sort of singularity problem?

Re: Sign restriction - Historical Decomposition

Posted: Tue May 05, 2015 11:11 am
by TomDoan
luching wrote:Hi Tom, I have a VAR with 2 variables only. In this system, is it possible to impose two sets of sign restrictions to identify two different structural shocks simultaneously and also impose that the two shocks are orthogonal? Doesn't this result in some sort of singularity problem?
Almost. Once you've picked one shock, the other is forced by the orthogonality constraint. However, you can still reject the pair of shocks if they don't meet a set of desired restrictions.